PubMedEcological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America2026-11-19
Decadal trade-offs between productivity and climate resilience in intensified native grasslands.
Caram Nicolas N, Casalás Felipe F, García-Favre Javier J, Zanoniani Ramiro R et al.
Grasslands cover approximately 40% of the global terrestrial area and support essential ecosystem services; however, productivity is commonly constrained by overgrazing and nitrogen (N) availability. Productivity can be boosted through improved grazing management and increased N supply, either indirectly via overseeding N-fixing legumes or directly through mineral N fertilization. Yet, how productivity gains from contrasting intensification pathways trade-off with resilience to climate variability remains underexplored. In a decade-long field experiment in Campos grassland that captured wide interannual rainfall variability, we evaluated seasonal and annual aboveground net primary production (ANPP), net secondary production (NSP), temporal stability (μ/σ), and trophic efficiency (NSP:ANPP) within a Bayesian hierarchical framework that jointly modeled mean production and its interannual variability. Responses were assessed across four management strategies under similar grazing management but differing in intensification level: native grassland (NG) without external inputs, legume-overseeded grassland with phosphorus (P) fertilization, and NGs fertilized with P and either 60 or 120 kg N ha-1 y-1. Intensification boosted annual ANPP from 5.6 Mg DM ha-1 (95% CI: 4.6-6.8) in NG to 6.2 Mg DM ha-1 (5.0-7.6) in the legume-overseeded grassland (+11%) and to 7.4 Mg DM ha-1 (6.1-8.8) under N fertilization (+32%). Responses saturated across N rates and differences were primarily driven by higher winter and spring ANPP. Associated with improved trophic efficiency, intensification determined disproportionate increases in annual NSP relative to ANPP: NG averaged 198 kg LW ha-1 (123-272), legume overseeded achieved 306 kg LW ha-1 (217-394; +54%), and N fertilized reached 416 kg LW ha-1 (300-529; +110%). Remarkably, intensification did not reduce temporal stability, as increases in production were accompanied by proportional increases in interannual variability. Nonetheless, intensification progressively increased the rainfall dependence of NSP, particularly during summer (R2 = 0.86). NSP shifted from negative to positive values at approximately 350 mm of summer rainfall (≈50% of summers since 1982) in N-fertilized grasslands, but at only approximately 200 mm (≈80% of summers) in native and legume-overseeded grasslands. Rather than revealing simple productivity-resilience trade-offs, these rainfall-dependent thresholds highlight the need to balance productivity gains against climatic risk probabilistically, providing actionable insights for climate-resilient grassland systems in the Anthropocene.