Intra-sulcular compound chamomile and lidocaine hydrochloride gel for procedural pain during ultrasonic scaling: a randomized, single-blind, split-mouth, sham-controlled superiority trial in adults with plaque-induced gingivitis.
Tang Rong R, Yin Tingting T, Liang Jia J, Wang Ruijie R et al.
This study aimed to evaluate whether intra-sulcular application of a compound chamomile and lidocaine hydrochloride gel (Kami-Gel) reduces procedural pain during ultrasonic supragingival scaling in adults with plaque-induced gingivitis compared with a sham procedure. A single-center, randomized, single-blind, split-mouth, sham-controlled superiority trial was conducted involving 114 adults with plaque-induced gingivitis. Participants received a sequential split-mouth treatment. The test side received intra-sulcular application of Kami-Gel, while the control side received a sham application (mimicked injection). The primary outcome was procedural pain intensity measured on a 0-10 Visual Analog Scale (VAS). Secondary outcomes included the number of pain complaints, procedural duration, patient satisfaction, and plaque index (PI). Safety was assessed immediately and at 24 h. All 114 participants completed the study. Median VAS score was significantly lower in the test group (1.7 [IQR: 0.62-2.58]) than the control group (4.1 [IQR: 2.42-5.7]), with an estimated treatment difference of - 2.35 (95% CI: -3.0 to - 1.7)-the upper limit of which fell below the pre-specified superiority margin of - 1.2, confirming superiority (P < 0.001). The test group also demonstrated significantly fewer pain complaints (median 0 vs. 1), shorter procedural duration (median 10 vs. 12 min), and higher patient satisfaction (all P < 0.001). Post-scaling plaque index was significantly lower in the test group (median 0.75 [IQR: 0.55-0.86] vs. 0.89 [IQR: 0.75-0.96]; P < 0.001), though this difference may reflect improved patient cooperation rather than a direct pharmacological effect. No adverse events were reported. Intra-sulcular application of compound chamomile and lidocaine hydrochloride gel reduces procedural pain during ultrasonic supragingival scaling compared to a sham procedure. Its use was associated with shorter active scaling time and higher satisfaction. Whether these acute benefits translate to improved long-term periodontal treatment compliance warrants further investigation. Intra-sulcular application of compound chamomile and lidocaine gel (Kami-Gel) prior to ultrasonic supragingival scaling reduces procedural pain and was associated with higher patient satisfaction. A lower post-scaling plaque index was observed in the test group, potentially attributable to improved patient cooperation during instrumentation. This safe, non-injectable chairside technique provides clinicians a practical tool to enhance patient comfort during scaling procedures.